Shanghai Girls (2009) | How Woke Is It?

Our VerdictMildly Woke

30%

Shanghai Girls2009

In a free society the right to critique art is essential and protected speech. These reviews reflect personal opinions and not statements of fact.

What We Think

Shanghai Girls is far from a woke manifesto. While it critiques historical injustices, it does so with nuance and a focus on character and family, not ideological sermonizing. Traditional values are acknowledged rather than dismissed.

Score Breakdown

Compromised:Narrative Integrity

Mildly Woke

What is this?

Shanghai Girls focuses mainly on the immigrant experience and the struggles of two Chinese sisters in America, prioritizing personality, family bonds, and survival over identity politics. Representation serves the plot and historical context rather than an imposed ideology, so narrative integrity mostly remains intact.

Compromised:Cultural Foundations

Mildly Woke

What is this?

The novel explores themes of family obligation, tradition, and cultural heritage, though it does highlight some oppressive aspects of traditional gender roles. Still, these critiques often come from within the culture rather than being imposed through a modern lens.

Compromised:Ideological Monoculture

Mildly Woke

What is this?

Although the book offers a critical view of American racism and sexism, it also gives space to Chinese customs and perspectives, allowing for nuanced discussion rather than mocking or flattening alternative viewpoints.

User Reviews

No user reviews received yet.

Please leave a review and let the world know what you think.
Your review will be kept completely anonymous.

Your Review

Comments

Users Also Viewed

Movie poster for LOUIS VUITTON AVEC LEA SEYDOUX

Movie poster for The Movie You Will Never See

Movie poster for TINY'S AVEC CHLOE PAQUET

Movie poster for CAPUCINES HANDBAGS COLLECTION

Mufasa : Le Roi Lion - Bande-annonce

Movie poster for Squid Game 3 - Bande Annonce

Movie poster for Un parfait inconnu - Bande Annoce

Movie poster for Wrightslaw: From Emotions To Advocacy The Special Education Survival Guide

Bharat: The Uncolonized

Disclaimer: In a free society the right to critique art is essential and protected as a form of free speech and freedom of expression. The reviews and commentary on this site represent personal opinions and interpretations. They are not statements of fact and should not be taken as factual claims about any individual, company, or creative work.