Fruitvale Station strongly centers its narrative around the identity and struggles of Oscar Grant, with a clear emphasis on themes of race and systemic injustice. While emotionally impactful, some viewers may feel that social commentary takes priority over more nuanced character development, at times risking a one-note perspective.

The film portrays family and fatherhood as valuable but largely focuses on the systemic failures faced by the protagonist. While faith, masculinity, and morality are present, traditional institutions are depicted mainly as sources of struggle rather than strength. It doesn’t outwardly mock tradition, but certainly sidesteps their positive roles.

Alternative viewpoints, such as police perspective, systemic complexity, or internal debate, are minimal. The narrative is tightly controlled, leading viewers toward one interpretation. Critics may see this as limiting complexity in favor of a single, ‘approved’ worldview, and dissenting views are noticeably absent or villainized.