'Joy' appears to place a heavy emphasis on identity issues and modern diversity checkboxes, to the point where character depth and traditional narrative arcs sometimes take a back seat. The film seems more interested in using its characters to make social statements than in crafting a balanced story. Some viewers may feel the plot is built around ideology rather than cohesive character motivation or organic growth.

The film takes a critical look at traditional cultural norms, particularly around family structures and religious values, which are often depicted as barriers to progress. Traditional beliefs and roles are challenged or outright dismissed, presenting a worldview where modern ideologies are consistently shown as morally superior to established customs.

Alternative perspectives, especially those reflecting more traditional or non-woke viewpoints, are largely absent or reduced to one-dimensional opposition. Most main characters share the same contemporary views, and the rare dissenting voices seem caricatured or used as narrative punching bags, leaving little room for genuine pluralism or debate.