Gears 5 noticeably pivots from its masculine, bro-heavy franchise roots by focusing on Kait Diaz, a female protagonist, and expanding identity-based character beats. Some fans argue this feels more like an answer to trends than natural storytelling. While the plot isn't all about ideology, it comes across as ticking boxes in places, especially with diverse side characters who sometimes overshadow returning leads.

Traditional masculinity and group camaraderie, once central to the series, are softened here. The shift away from classic tough-guy motifs to center more sensitive, introspective characters can seem calculated. Gender roles are subverted, and there's less emphasis on family or legacy compared to previous games, which might feel like downplaying classic values.

While there aren't heavy-handed lectures, the game gives little room for alternative perspectives; most characters accept the new tone without much pushback. 'Traditional' attitudes are rarely shown sincerely, and the cast uniformly embraces modern sensibilities. It's more subtle than some, but nevertheless point-for-point with current trends.