Much of "A Little Late with Lilly Singh" appears crafted around identity-focused topics, with repeated emphasis on race, sexuality, and gender, sometimes at the expense of broader late-night format appeal or comedic variety. The focus on personal background and social commentary often overshadows traditional character or narrative-driven entertainment.

The show frequently subverts and critiques traditional notions of family, gender roles, and cultural heritage. Masculinity is often the subject of jokes, while Singh positions herself and other non-traditional identities as superior or more enlightened, which can be seen as undermining conventional values.

Alternative or non-progressive viewpoints are rarely explored, and dissenting opinions are often lampooned or used as setups for punchlines. The tone is consistently anchored in modern, left-leaning social attitudes with little room for pluralism or debate.