The show often appears to foreground identity, race, gender, and sexuality, over organic storytelling, sometimes sidelining more nuanced character arcs in favor of social commentary. Many scenarios feel built to serve a message, rather than to develop character or drama in a traditional sense.

‘American Crime’ frequently questions or critiques traditional family, religion, and cultural roles. Masculinity is often examined through a critical lens, with traditional figures portrayed as problematic or outdated. This approach is clearly meant to push audiences to rethink norms, but it tends to reduce authentic representation of such values.

The show's worldview leans heavily into progressive assumptions on race, gender, and power. Traditionalist perspectives are usually relegated to antagonists or deeply flawed characters, with little room for genuine debate or ideological diversity among the main cast.