The show largely sticks to the facts of the O.J. Simpson case, but there are moments where identity politics are brought front and center, sometimes overshadowing the legal drama. Some viewers might feel that the narrative leans heavily into social commentary about race and celebrity, occasionally at the expense of exploring deeper personal complexity.

While the show critiques certain traditional institutions, it mostly presents the cultural context of the 1990s rather than aggressively rewriting it. The series does suggest morality and justice are social constructs, sometimes undermining classic notions of right and wrong in favor of modern perspectives.

The series frames dissenting views on the case, especially those skeptical of the mainstream narrative, as fringe or outdated, rarely making space for outspokenly non-woke perspectives. The cultural conversation is largely filtered through a present-day lens.