Brigands: The Quest for Gold appears to prioritize diversity and identity over historical plausibility at times, with characters whose traits and storylines seem adapted to fit modern ideological preferences more than genuine narrative needs. Some viewers may find that this undermines immersion and the believability of the 18th-century setting, sacrificing traditional storytelling for contemporary social commentary.

The series reinterprets historical gender roles and power dynamics by centering female and marginalized characters in positions of unusual influence for the time period. While this may be empowering for some, it tends to downplay traditional masculinity, religion, and family, reflecting a fashionable skepticism toward foundational Western values.

Most characters display modern attitudes toward gender and class, with traditional perspectives either absent or reduced to shallow antagonism. Sincere discussion of alternative worldviews is noticeably lacking, giving the impression of an ideological echo chamber prevalent in much of contemporary streaming content.