Chamak does seem intent on emphasizing identity, particularly as it focuses on issues of caste and representation in the Punjabi music industry. While some characters are nuanced, the emphasis on social messages can feel shoehorned and might overshadow individual character arcs and organic narrative development. Identity is foregrounded more than earned personal growth.

The show appears to engage in cultural critique, especially regarding caste and traditional power dynamics. Established cultural and social hierarchies are challenged and often portrayed as obstacles. While this brings important topics to the fore, it also tends to present traditional structures mainly in a negative light, which may feel dismissive to some audiences.

Chamak mostly dwells in one ideological lane, with alternative perspectives rarely receiving depth or credibility. Traditional points of view are often depicted as antagonistic, with little genuine internal debate or pluralism visible. It’s clear which worldview is meant to be embraced.