While "Cheer" focuses on determination, teamwork, and athleticism, it also puts significant emphasis on identity narratives, particularly around race, sexuality, and overcoming adversity, sometimes at the expense of broader team dynamics or the technical rigor of the sport. The storytelling occasionally feels guided more by identity arcs than the actual process of competitive cheerleading.

The show tends to spotlight non-traditional family structures and struggles, and often frames traditional Southern values as quaint or outdated. While it celebrates perseverance, it arguably leans into redefining success and family in line with modern values, sometimes diminishing more conventional perspectives.

Alternative worldviews receive some airtime, but rarely escape being depicted as obstacles to be overcome. Most narratives drift toward progressive or modern attitudes, with limited genuine debate or plurality. Those with differing views are presented with sympathy, but rarely as fully valid alternatives.