Council of Dads leans heavily into identity-driven casting and storylines, with major focus on diverse backgrounds (race, gender, sexuality) often taking center stage over organic character development. Story arcs sometimes seem designed to tick boxes rather than serve narrative logic, which can be interpreted as prioritizing message over merit.

Traditional notions of family, masculinity, and religion are consistently reinterpreted. The show features non-traditional family structures and frequently frames the nuclear family as outdated, while more progressive arrangements are depicted as superior, almost without critique.

Alternative viewpoints are largely absent or gently mocked. Traditional perspectives rarely receive a fair hearing and are typically embodied by characters portrayed as out-of-touch or barriers to progress. The show exudes a sense of consensus on modern values, minimizing internal debate.