Eden appears to heavily prioritize identity and representation in its casting and character arcs, sometimes at the expense of coherent storytelling and character realism. Several characters seem to exist mainly as vessels for modern ideological talking points, rather than organic participants in the plot, which can make the story feel contrived and less engaging for those seeking traditional narrative structures.

The show often challenges and even undermines traditional notions of family, religion, and especially masculinity. Male characters are frequently depicted as flawed or regressive, while female and non-binary characters are elevated as inherently right or progressive. Traditional values are largely portrayed as outdated or problematic, which can be jarring for viewers expecting more balance.

Alternative viewpoints are typically underrepresented or vilified, with most dissenting characters reduced to exaggerations or stereotypes. Dialogue and plot developments reinforce a single ideological worldview, with little space for debate or complexity. This lack of pluralism can make the series feel like an echo chamber for current cultural trends.