Guns Germs & Steel (2005) | How Woke Is It?

Our VerdictWoke

63%

Guns Germs & Steel2005

In a free society the right to critique art is essential and protected speech. These reviews reflect personal opinions and not statements of fact.

What We Think

While well-produced, the series tends to elevate a revisionist, environmental determinist lens, leaving little room for cultural nuance or competing worldviews. Not the wokest show out there, but it’s definitely leaning in that direction.

Score Breakdown

Compromised:Narrative Integrity

Woke

What is this?

The show adapts Jared Diamond’s book, focusing on environmental and geographic factors over individual achievement or culture. While it just about avoids overt identity box-ticking, its framework leans strongly toward ideology-driven narratives over traditional storytelling.

Compromised:Cultural Foundations

Woke

What is this?

Guns, Germs & Steel often downplays the influence of traditional values, religion, and cultural ingenuity, instead crediting geography and environment for civilizational outcomes. This can be seen as diminishing the role of cultural heritage or individual initiative.

Compromised:Ideological Monoculture

Woke

What is this?

Alternative viewpoints that stress cultural, religious, or nationalist factors are largely absent or dismissed. The show presents a singular, environmentalist determinist perspective, with little room for debate or pluralism.

User Reviews

No user reviews received yet.

Please leave a review and let the world know what you think.
Your review will be kept completely anonymous.

Your Review

Comments

Users Also Viewed

Movie poster for Treasure Seekers: Tibet's Hidden Kingdom

Movie poster for How to Survive the End of the World

Movie poster for National Geographic : Search for the Afghan Girl

Movie poster for Drugged: High on Alcohol

The Skyjacker That Got Away

Disclaimer: In a free society the right to critique art is essential and protected as a form of free speech and freedom of expression. The reviews and commentary on this site represent personal opinions and interpretations. They are not statements of fact and should not be taken as factual claims about any individual, company, or creative work.