"I Just Killed My Dad" centers on a real-life criminal case, focusing intently on the events and psychology of the individuals involved. There is little sign that identity-driven narratives or forced representation overshadow the storytelling. The docuseries seems more concerned with the complexities and nuances of the case itself than with ticking modern ideological boxes.

The series explores family dysfunction, trauma, and the justice system without overtly undermining traditional cultural or moral foundations. Some critique of parental authority arises, but it is contextual and not driven by a clear ideological agenda. Masculinity and family are not actively mocked or subverted.

Alternative perspectives are considered, including interviews with various parties and legal experts. The documentary appears open to multiple interpretations rather than pushing a singular, modern ideological frame, allowing viewers to draw their own conclusions from the evidence provided.