Some viewers might feel the docuseries places an outsized emphasis on Aaron Hernandez's sexuality, framing it as a critical piece in understanding his actions. While undeniably relevant, this focus sometimes overshadows other motives or circumstances, which could make it seem like the show leans on identity angles at the expense of more complex storytelling.

The series occasionally hints that cultural pressures around masculinity and sexuality in sports are inherently repressive or toxic, subtly undermining traditional values. While this analysis adds depth, it could be interpreted as pathologizing masculinity and linking it too closely with negative outcomes, which feels a bit heavy-handed at times.

Alternative perspectives, such as traditional views on masculinity or family, are mostly presented as problematic, with little nuanced defense. The narrative doesn't sincerely engage with or empathize with these viewpoints, favoring a more modern, progressive framing throughout, potentially leaving some viewers feeling shut out.