Monsterland often foregrounds identity and social issues, at times at the expense of consistent character development or internal story logic. Several episodes appear more interested in delivering commentary on race, gender, or class than maintaining coherent supernatural narratives. This approach, while ambitious, can sometimes feel heavy-handed.

The series tends to critique or reframe traditional themes like religion, family, and masculinity, often implying that these are sources of trauma or backwardness. Positive portrayals of such cultural foundations are rare and, when present, are usually quickly undermined or dismissed for emphasis on more modern values.

The show's worldview is starkly one-sided. Alternative or traditional perspectives are virtually always depicted through villains or tragic figures, rarely with depth or sympathy. There is little genuine debate or ideological diversity, promoting a clear and unyielding ideological message.