In our view, "Mr. McMahon" places noticeable emphasis on identity politics and social themes, sometimes at the expense of raw storytelling and character complexity. Certain character backstories, motivations, and major events appear shaped more by contemporary ideological trends than organic narrative progression. This could be seen as prioritizing message over craft.

The show seems to frequently critique traditional values (masculinity, hierarchy, even aspects of family life) and frames them in a negative light. Religious and moral themes are filtered through a thoroughly modern lens. For viewers seeking authentic, non-woke cultural representation, the balance definitely tilts toward revisionism.

Alternative worldviews or traditional stances are largely absent except as thin caricatures; dissenters are quickly sidelined or presented as regressive obstacles. The show heavily implies a singular set of values is correct, with little sincere exploration of real debate or pluralism.