“Orange Is the New Black” consistently highlights diversity and identity, sometimes to the detriment of traditional storytelling. A significant emphasis is placed on race, sexuality, and gender over classic character development or merit-driven arcs, occasionally making these themes feel front-and-center rather than earning their relevance organically.

The show openly challenges traditional notions around family, religion, and especially masculinity. Male characters often appear weak or villainous, and classic values are frequently mocked or reimagined. This subversion appears central to its tone rather than a nuanced critique, making its cultural stance very overt.

Dissenting or more traditional voices are typically absent or portrayed as caricatures (often as close-minded antagonists). Practically every major character falls in line with modern progressive orthodoxy, with little legitimate debate or pluralism presented on sensitive cultural issues.