Pretty Smart puts a lot of emphasis on its diverse cast, with identity factors taking center stage over nuanced personality development. Many storylines appear crafted primarily to highlight modern social issues. This can make episodes feel formulaic and character arcs a bit shallow, as if narrative depth sometimes takes a back seat to messaging.

The show consistently pokes fun at traditional values like family roles and masculinity, often playing them for laughs or as out-of-touch. Characters representing more traditional views are typically portrayed as naïve, while progressive perspectives tend to be validated, giving the impression of a modern re-education camp disguised as a sitcom.

Alternative viewpoints are mostly played for laughs or painted as outmoded in Pretty Smart. The main cast embraces the same contemporary moral assumptions, and any differing voices rarely last more than a punchline before being dismissed. Serious debate or worldview conflict is pretty much non-existent.