The show's entire premise is centered on pitting female teams from different professional backgrounds against each other in competitive survival games. While the concept is fresh, it leans heavily on showcasing women in roles typically portrayed by men, sometimes at the expense of deeper character development or realistic context. This can give the impression of ideology overriding organic storytelling.

Siren: Survive the Island explicitly subverts traditional gender roles by focusing entirely on women's physical prowess and teamwork, often in environments or challenges where men historically predominate. This can be seen as downplaying traditional family and masculine roles, though the show stops short of openly criticizing such institutions.

The absence of male competitors and a persistent celebration of female empowerment create a somewhat one-sided ideological tone. While not outright villainizing alternatives, the series maintains a largely singular worldview and doesn't represent much diversity in gender perspective or traditional viewpoints.