The show places strong emphasis on sexuality and identity, sometimes allowing these themes to overshadow more traditional character arcs or family-driven storylines. While it does have real emotional stakes, the focus on certain ideological messaging can sometimes come at the expense of narrative subtlety or nuance.

South of Nowhere frequently presents traditional family, religion, and gender roles as sources of conflict or barriers to self-expression. Masculinity and faith are often framed through a critical, modern lens. The show tends to favor progressive interpretations over established norms, leading to a noticeable undermining of cultural foundations.

There is a clear tilt towards one worldview; dissenters or those with traditional views are mainly depicted as obstacles or antagonists. Sincere alternative perspectives are rarely validated or deeply explored, resulting in limited pluralism.