"That Cover Girl" strongly prioritizes identity themes, often casting characters based on modern diversity checklists rather than organic fit for the story. Several leads feel selected for representational value, and their conflicts revolve more around identity issues than personal growth or skill. This can come across as box-ticking rather than genuine character development.

The show frequently treats traditional family dynamics and masculine values as outdated, promoting alternative lifestyles as more enlightened. Parental figures and older authority are usually dismissive or ridiculed, with the spotlight on progressive interpretations of family, gender, and career. Any nod to tradition is generally negative or played for laughs.

There's little room for dissent in "That Cover Girl;" anyone holding traditional or non-woke opinions is often depicted as bigoted or clueless, if given any voice at all. Practically all major characters align with a singular, modern view on identity issues. No genuine internal debate or pluralism appears present in the show's worldview.