"American Me" focuses primarily on authenticity in its story and character development. The film prioritizes a gritty, realistic portrayal of gang culture, with diverse casting rooted in the realities of East LA rather than shoehorning identity politics. Narrative integrity remains largely intact, with personal arcs and consequences stemming from believable motivations.

The film does not overtly mock or undermine traditional values; instead, it examines family, masculinity, and culture under the strain of crime and broken institutions. It depicts the tragic collapse of these foundations rather than ridiculing them, maintaining a grounded approach to its cultural setting.

Alternative perspectives aren’t demonized; rather, the film complexly portrays its characters' struggles and environments. The morality is not cartoonishly modern or woke, and the film avoids one-dimensional villains representing traditionalism. Instead, it presents layered conflicts without excessive ideological preaching.