Fear Street: 1994 heavily foregrounds identity-based storylines, particularly with its LGBTQ+ lead couple and diverse cast. Some viewers may feel that these elements are inserted mainly to send a message, rather than enhance the plot or create well-rounded characters. The story often spotlights identity aspects over deeper character development or internal conflict, which can make the narrative feel secondary.

The film subverts traditional gender roles by centering on a queer female lead who is portrayed as unflinchingly capable. Religious characters are often depicted as ignorant or villainous, and classic family structures are largely sidelined. This could be seen as an intentional update to align with modern values, rather than a genuine exploration of the era.

Fear Street: 1994 offers minimal space for traditional or dissenting worldviews. Characters with conservative perspectives appear as antagonistic or regressive, with little nuance. The dominant outlook throughout the film is modern and progressive, and alternative views are generally not depicted sympathetically or given real screen time.