Obi-Wan Kenobi often appears to sacrifice established lore and character arcs in favor of identity-driven casting and messaging. The show introduces new characters whose primary features seem to be their identity traits, especially Reva, who receives significant focus and narrative importance, sometimes at the expense of established leads. This may frustrate viewers wanting authentic storytelling centered on classic Star Wars themes and characters.

The series tends to downplay traditional masculine heroism in favor of elevating female and minority characters, who frequently display few flaws or internal struggles. While some legacy characters are sidelined or diminished, newer characters are portrayed as morally upright or hyper-capable. There are also notable instances of reinterpretation of beloved Star Wars lore to match more current social values.

Dissenting or traditional perspectives are scarce in the show, with 'old guard' characters often shown as outdated or ineffectual. The narrative tone clearly favors contemporary views on identity and justice, offering little internal challenge or philosophical variety. Those not aligned with the dominant worldview are usually painted as villains or obstacles rather than nuanced alternatives.