The Innocence Files is a documentary series focused on wrongful convictions, often spotlighting issues of race and systemic bias. While its intentions are heartfelt, some may see the show framing stories in ways that highlight identity factors over broader aspects of justice. The narrative sometimes leans more into activism than pure storytelling, but it still roots itself in the real-life journeys of those affected.

The series frequently critiques aspects of law enforcement, the justice system, and even elements of traditional authority, viewing them as sources of injustice. It frames the problems as systemic and deeply rooted, which some viewers might feel undermines cultural trust in long-standing institutions. While it values empathy, it rarely reinforces or explores traditional morality or cultural norms.

Alternative viewpoints, particularly those supporting the integrity of the justice system, are given minimal attention or appear as antagonistic. The series presents a clear worldview, systemic injustice is rampant, without much engagement with counter-narratives or internal debate, leading to a fairly uniform ideological perspective throughout.