The Stolen Girl appears to heavily prioritize identity and social justice narratives over organic story progression. Characterization often hinges on identity markers rather than individual development or plot-driven growth. Some viewers may find that character arcs feel secondary to messaging, with merit or real-world logic taking a noticeable backseat to ideological themes.

Traditional family structures and religious values are either absent, depicted as problematic, or used as foils for the more enlightened perspectives of the main characters. There's an unmistakable push to upend expectations around gender roles, with depictions of masculinity frequently undermined, and historic or cultural references tailored to fit present-day sensibilities.

The show shows little tolerance for alternative worldviews. Characters who dissent from the show's main ideological thrust are often painted in simplistic, unflattering ways. Nuanced debate is swapped for uniformity, practically everyone is on-message, leaving little room for meaningful discussion or credible opposition.