Three Pines appears to place a significant focus on identity-driven narratives, particularly around Indigenous issues. Characters are frequently defined more by their identity markers than rich personal arcs, and several episodes seem designed to elevate ideological points rather than organic character or plot development. Some viewers might find the story secondary to the message.

The series often highlights systemic issues with policing, traditional authority, and Canada's national narrative. Family, religious, and traditional masculine roles are either sidelined or subverted, making these themes feel out of step with the show's modern moral focus. Traditional cultural elements are depicted as flawed or problematic.

Alternative viewpoints to the prevailing progressive narrative are largely absent or characterized by ignorant antagonists. There’s little space given to nuanced opposition or true pluralism, and traditional perspectives are explored mainly as institutional failings or sources of harm.